Squarespace, Webflow, WordPress or Shopify?

Which website platform is right for your business?

‍

If you've ever tried to research which website platform to use, you'll know the internet is full of opinions. Most of them are written by people who use one platform and want to tell you why it's the best.

So here's my version.

‍

There is no single right answer to which platform is best. There's just the right answer for your situation, your business, your budget, your technical confidence, and what you actually need your site to do. Here's a straightforward comparison without an ulterior motive.

‍

Squarespace

‍

Best for: Service businesses, creatives, consultants, coaches, authors, and anyone who wants a beautiful, manageable site without needing technical skills.

‍

Squarespace is the platform I find myself recommending most often, not because it's the flashiest option, but because it genuinely suits the majority of small businesses.

‍

Everything is handled for you. Hosting, security, updates, all included in one monthly subscription. The editor is intuitive enough that most people can make basic updates themselves without any training. And the price is predictable, no surprises, no add-ons you didn't ask for.

‍

If you're building your own site using Squarespace's templates, there are enough good ones to get you somewhere decent. But it's worth being honest: a DIY Squarespace site tends to look like a Squarespace site. The templates are well-designed, but they're widely used so the result can feel generic. When I build on Squarespace I design from scratch rather than adapting a template.

‍

Where Squarespace falls short is flexibility. If you want highly custom layouts, complex filtering, or specific behaviour that doesn't exist natively, you'll hit walls. The SEO tools are decent, only at a basic level. And for content-heavy sites, large blogs, portfolio libraries, structured content, the CMS can start to feel limiting.

‍

Choose Squarespace if: You're a service business, author, coach, or creative who wants to look good online, manage updates yourself, and doesn't need anything particularly custom.

‍

Webflow

‍

Best for: Businesses that need a custom, polished design and a content-heavy site they can grow into, without relying on a developer for every change.

‍

Webflow sits between a website builder and a development tool. The design freedom is much closer to what you'd get from a fully custom-coded site, without the cost of building one from scratch. You can build layouts that simply aren't possible in Squarespace, and the CMS is genuinely flexible.

‍

The SEO control is better than Squarespace, the interactions and animations are more sophisticated, and the sites that come out of Webflow tend to feel more custom and considered. It's where I enjoy building sites the most as a designer because it gives me the flexibility to build exactly what a project needs rather than adapting to what a template allows.

‍

The honest downside is the learning curve. Webflow takes more getting used to than Squarespace, it's more powerful but more complex, and making updates without understanding the structure can occasionally cause things to go wrong. I spend time on handover making sure you're comfortable with it, but it's not as  intuitive as a drag-and-drop editor. It's also more expensive to run than Squarespace, and for some small businesses that extra cost isn't justified.

‍

Where Webflow earns its place is for businesses that have outgrown a template but can't justify a fully custom-coded site. If you care deeply about your brand, want precise control over how things look and behave, and you have a growing amount of content to manage, it's often the right call.

‍

Choose Webflow if: You want design freedom and a scalable CMS, you care about how your site looks at a granular level, and you're willing to invest a bit more time learning the platform, or happy to hand over any maintenane and updates to your designer.

‍

WordPress

‍

Best for: Content-heavy sites, blogs, membership sites, and businesses that need deep customisation and want full ownership of their platform.

‍

WordPress is the oldest and most widely used platform on this list, it powers around 40 percent of all websites. The plugin library is enormous. If you need something, there's almost certainly a plugin for it. And because so many developers work in WordPress, the pool of people who can help you with it is large.

‍

But most used doesn't mean most suitable. WordPress is also the platform I see most often causing problems for small businesses who weren't quite ready for it.

‍

It requires more maintenance than the others, plugin updates, security patches, occasional conflicts between plugins that break things unexpectedly. Hosting is separate, which means an extra decision and an extra cost. And the quality of WordPress sites varies enormously depending on the theme and how it's been set up. A badly-built WordPress site is genuinely worse than a well-built Squarespace one.

‍

For a new small business website in 2026, it's rarely my first recommendation, not because it's bad, but because Squarespace and Webflow now cover most of what small businesses actually need, with significantly less overhead.

‍

WordPress makes sense when you need things the other platforms can't do: a membership or course site, a highly complex blog, a multilingual site, very deep customisation, or a business that specifically needs to stay on WordPress because their team already knows it.

‍

Choose WordPress if: You need extensive plugin functionality, you're building a membership or course site, you want complete ownership of your codebase, or your team already works in it.

‍

Shopify

‍

Best for: Product-based businesses where ecommerce is the primary purpose of the site.

‍

Shopify is an ecommerce platform. It's excellent at what it does, selling products online, but it's not really a competitor to the others for most of the businesses I work with.

‍

If you're selling physical products, have meaningful stock to manage, or need a serious online shop, Shopify is worth looking at seriously. The inventory tools, payment integrations, and checkout experience are very well built. The running costs are higher than the other platforms here, and every sale comes with a transaction fee unless you use Shopify Payments,worth factoring in before you commit.

‍

Choose Shopify if: You're running a product-based business with meaningful stock and ecommerce is the point of the site.

‍

How to choose the right website platform for your small business

‍

If you're still not sure, here's the framework I use when a client asks me:

‍

You want to manage it yourself with minimal fuss - Squarespace

You care about custom design and have a lot of content - Webflow

You need complex functionality or already have a WordPress site - WordPress

You're selling products and ecommerce is the point - Shopify

‍

The question that matters most is: what does your site actually need to do? Start there and the platform choice usually follows naturally.

‍

If you're not sure, that's exactly what an intro call is for. I'll ask the right questions and tell you honestly which platform suits your situation, even if that means pointing you somewhere other than where I normally build.